Advance Review: GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY #18

GARGAL2013018_DC11

GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY #18
Written by Brian Michael Bendis
Art by Ed McGuinness
Published by Marvel Comics
Release Date: August 27, 2014

A burning question is finally asked as Peter Quill is put in the hot seat about what really went down in the Cancerverse in Guardians of the Galaxy #18.

Folks who have been reading the Marvel Cosmic books for the past few years, or have caught up with all the Guardians movie buzz have been wondering something for well over a year now: what the hell happened to Richard Ryder? Prior to this iteration of Guardians of the Galaxy being launched, readers assumed Nova, Star-Lord and Thanos were engaged in a battle royale for the ages in the Cancerverse, and then, seemingly out of nowhere, Star-Lord and Thanos are back on the scene. What went down? Where is Richard Ryder?

Brian Michael Bendis is finally going to give readers some closure, starting with this issue of Guardians. Bendis sets up the situation well, highlighting the relevant information to be able to understand the story if you haven’t read the older issues, and bring you back up to speed if it has been awhile. He handles these characters well, Star-Lord is very consistently Star-Lord, and Thanos is as conniving and cunning as ever. I was impressed by how well Bendis writes Richard Ryder, and just how badly I found I want that character back to at least serve as a mentor to young Sam Alexander. The dynamic between Star-Lord and Nova is great, a Rocket/Groot-level bromance that is a ton of fun to read, and their banter brings a great dynamic to this issue.

Bendis keeps the surprises coming as the story unfolds, and leaves things hanging at a skillfully timed cliffhanger. You’ll be wanting issue #19 badly when you finish this one, I can guarantee you that. While this issue does not contain the big reveal of exactly what happened in the Cancerverse, it is well written and sets up a foundation for a great next issue. Rather than rush this story and slam it into a single comic, Bendis paces it nicely, giving readers a good glimpse at what happened in this other universe without rushing it and cheating readers of a fleshed out story.

Ed McGuinness pencils this issue well, highlighting the power of all the characters involved very well. These are heavy hitters in this issue, and McGuinness makes sure you don’t forget it. He builds a dynamic and dangerous Cancerverse and an imposing Thanos, showcasing the threat that Nova and Star-Lord are facing in this place. He handles the big action sequences well, but some of his strongest work is during the less-intense portions of the issue. He uses shadow very well throughout the issue, not something I typically associate with Ed McGuinness, and it tempers the colourful and dynamic images in the Cancerverse well. Guardians of the Galaxy has featured an all-star cast of artists, and McGuinness holds his own with this issue.

Guardians of the Galaxy #18 is a rock solid comic that brings readers closer to the answers of what happened to the original Nova and how Thanos came back on the scene to wreak the havoc that was Infinity. It doesn’t get more A-list than Bendis and McGuinness and the two bring their best to this issue. It is a must-read for Guardians fans and anyone who has read the Cosmic titles in the past decade. That last page will grab you, and I know I’m itching for #19.

The Verdict: 8.5/10

 

Authors

Related posts

7 Comments

  1. juice005 said:

    It would seem Marvel has changed that…I’ll admit to doing a double take when I first saw it in the early pages.

  2. This guy right here said:

    His name is RIDER. Just because Bendis got it wrong, doesn’t mean you should.

  3. B3taBlock3r said:

    That was a frustratingly short book.

    LIGHT SPOILERS AHEAD

    Here’s the praise:
    I think it’s right that Gamora is the one to give Starlord a quizzing about these events, after all she and Nova were close for a while. Although it seems unlikely she’s going to go full Casino Royale on tied up Pete, I think it’s pretty clear that the message here is rather that it’s Marvel editorial in the chair and the readership making vaguely angry noises whilst being totally unthreatening. So I like the framing here.
    The art is great.
    Thanos feels like Thanos which makes a nice change.

    Here’s the crits:
    the “Rich” and “Pete” relationship which dates back to Annihilation really wasn’t there. Pete was always the “Hawkeye” to Nova’s “Cap”. In my mind at least.
    Nova hardly ever gets a panel to himself.
    Drax in the cancerverse doesn’t make any sense. Seriously. What?
    And the annihilation style crab monsters should win a prize for “plot device least likely to kill anyone ever.”

    In review : Meh. I had high expectations I guess and they were more than this issue could fill.

    Prediction: Rich bites the bullet in the next ish in one panel which is immediately glossed over and then we’re stuck with BNDesque Ultimate-Spiderman-Nova. Richard Rider fans continue to be irked.

  4. zaphod703 said:

    I agree with you…. Very Meh issue… Alot of problems (Ryder spelling was horrible)… But on Drax surprisingly for once Bendis got that right actually. Drax was destroyed (all body blown apart) in the Cancerverse in Thanos Imperative #4. So I can see Bendis logic there (though it is usually very hard to see)

  5. B3taBlock3r said:

    You are absolutely spot on there. I had somehow convinced myself that took place on Knowhere. TI4 was a great book…
    Anyway that also raises odd questions such as why has Gamora forgotten that Drax died there as she was present, is this also a revision of the idea that Thanos can no longer die due to Death rejecting him because now his resurrection was also a cancerverse effect and (getting really picky) why aren’t Drax and Thanos now demonic cancerversions of themselves?
    I don’t know what I expected really. It’s nice that Marvel are investing in their cosmic stories but since the reshuffle it’s never been quite as cool as the post Annihilation setup.

Top